Thurrock Exposes Transparency Blind Spot

Thurrock Exposes Transparency Blind Spot

September 8, 2022
Open data, Procurement

An investigation by The Bureau of Investigative Journalism (TBIJ) into investments by Thurrock Borough Council has led to the resignation of the Council Leader and the Government has now stepped in and Essex County Council will run their finance team.

TBIJ’s investigation has taken three years and focuses on large investments from multiple councils in firms run by Liam Kavanagh. That the investigation took quite so long has, in large parts, been down to the failure of transparency.

In the UK, and particularly in English Local Government, we are proud of the levels of transparency that are required of local government. All budgets are published, payments above £500 are published, contracts over £25,000 are published, tenders are published and standing orders, council minutes and policies are all published. There is no question that there is a clear intention to give local residents a fulsome insight into the strategies, policies and financial commitments made by each and every Council.

So it has been disappointing to see that the investments that Thurrock Council have made have not been made transparent and don’t appear to require transparency. TBIJ has repeatedly requested data on these investments and after three years was able to report that 150 Councils had invested up to one billion pounds with Thurrock, who’s debt is set to rocket to an eye watering £2bn. The identities of those investors still hasn’t been revealed.

There’s a clear case for making data on investments by public sector bodies transparent. After all, if a Council has to detail a £500 transaction for gardening, then being transparent about a billion pound investment scheme should be routine. It is understandable that public spending on services are exposed to transparency, a resident should be able to know how much is paid for emptying their bins, but if an investment scheme becomes a genuine threat to the financial viability of the institution the risk to services is even greater than a poorly negotiated waste management contract.

We can see from the 1Malaysia Development Berhad scandal as well as corruption in Africa and Latin America, that investments have increasingly become the mechanism through which Governments have corruptly moved money to individuals. Traditional accounts are insufficient to bring true transparency to investment activities, true, structured data on public sector is investments is becoming an urgent requirement if we are to tackle corruption in public administrations.

Gareth Davies, the diligent TBIJ journalist who has broken this story has used our data in the past and we spoke to him about the limits of transparency in relation to Thurrock. That we couldn’t help him showed that a real problem existed, he deserves significant credit for his commitment to this story. My friend and colleague Sanan Mirzoyev has written about the similarities between Malaysia and South Africa here.

For completeness we are making no accusation of corruption in Thurrock, but we shall be watching with interest the conclusion of any investigation into whether there was a breach of any laws.

If you’d like to discuss our work in global government procurement, or find out more about our data API, get in touch,.

Because you read this article, you may be interested in reading UK Left Waiting On Transparency.

 

September 29, 2022

£900k Government Fund To Help Charities Win Public Contracts.

The Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport (DCMS) is running a Voluntary, Community and Social Enterprise (VCSE) Contract Readiness Fund grant...
September 27, 2022

New EU Procurement Instrument Now Law.

About a year ago, we wrote an article on the new procurement instrument approved by the European Union. In recent weeks this...
September 20, 2022

Blacklisting Gets Tested.

Back in June we wrote about blacklisting of suppliers and the Government’s intention to prevent poorly performing suppliers from bidding for government...
September 8, 2022

UK Risks Its Place On Anti-Corruption Body

The UK has been placed ‘under review’ by the 77-country-strong Open Government Partnership (OGP) due to its failure to meet mandatory criteria...
September 6, 2022

New Zealand Government Reviewing Procurement System.

It’s always encouraging when we see governments around the world looking to improve their procurement transparency and efficiency. The New Zealand Government...
September 1, 2022

Collecting Data For Sustainable Procurement In Construction

Over the last few weeks we have been looking at setting a sustainable procurement framework in the construction industry, and what kind...
August 30, 2022

Selecting Data For Sustainable Procurement In Construction

It is estimated that around 40-50% of natural resources are transformed into construction material, and that as much as 30% of all...
August 25, 2022

Setting A Sustainable Procurement Framework For Construction

When procuring construction projects, it can be useful to underpin sustainability criteria on existing policy and regulation. When assessing the enabling framework,...
August 18, 2022

Big Net Zero Contract Win For Small Cornish Business

A small Cornish company has purportedly won a £70bn contract to help deliver the country's transition to Net Zero. The Penzance based...
August 16, 2022

Supporting Sustainable Procurement In ICT

One of the key challenges of sustainably procuring ICT lies in the lack of transparency in supply chains. To overcome this challenge,...
August 11, 2022

Why Is Sustainable Procurement Important For The ICT Sector?

The extraction of raw materials, manufacturing, transportation, use, and disposal of ICT products is associated with a number of environmental, social, and...
August 10, 2022

Shifts Towards Sustainable Sourcing

A while ago,  we shared an article on findings by the Boston Consulting Group and the World Economic Forum that showed procurement is responsible...
August 9, 2022

Supporting Sustainable Procurement In The Construction Industry

Construction projects are usually long and complex, involving the participation of different stakeholders throughout the different project stages. There are certain factors...
August 4, 2022

Why Is Open SPP Important In The Construction Sector?

The construction industry is estimated to account for 6% of global GDP, with Africa's construction market valued at around USD 5.4 billion...
August 2, 2022

US Advances Equity And Economic Opportunity Through Procurement.

With the implementation of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, the Biden-Harris Administration set an objective to ensure federal investments built wealth and opportunity...

Newsletter

Compelling research, insights and data directly into your inbox.

Recent media stories

The Times
May 30, 2022
CIPFA
August 3, 2021

Search

Scroll to Top