Empty Fishing Lakes.

Empty Fishing Lakes.

May 24, 2022
Procurement

We’ve written before about frameworks, but some improved analysis from our brilliant data team made us think it was time to revisit the issue.

Using frameworks should lead to fewer tenders and more efficiency, but if there are too many, the promised efficiency improvements never materialise and suppliers can end up bidding into a tender that has no business behind it. Also known as the empty fishing lake problem, where a supplier spends time and money getting onto a framework but is never invited to bid for a contract.

This creates a dilemma for the supplier. Not bidding means never being able to win any of the subsequent contract opportunities, but bidding into an empty framework means wasting money on bids that will deliver no revenue.

Our data shows that the UK may well be seeing too many frameworks in place. Over 7% of the 60,000 tenders we let in the last two years were frameworks. Whilst that doesn’t seem overwhelming, there are some worrying concentrations of frameworks. Of the 150 tenders for Construction Consultancy Services, 78 were frameworks. Whilst Legal advisory services and Engineering design services saw more than 150 frameworks let in the last two years.

Across different types of consultancy we found 10,000 tenders in the last 24 months, but nearly 900 frameworks. Some frameworks include hundreds of suppliers, others are more modest, but the strong implication is that there simply isn’t enough business being commissioned to sustain this number of frameworks.

The obvious answer is for government to monitor these contracts, but problems are compounded by the lack of data. There is no formal way to identify frameworks (we have to estimate) and there’s no way to know how much spend went through individual frameworks. This leaves suppliers without critical information, they just have to hope that they’re not spending time trying to get a fishing license for an empty fishing lake.

Governments could greatly assist suppliers trying to compete for public contracts by doing something to tackle this issue. They could start by publishing more data on frameworks, for instance showing whether similar frameworks already exist for a given category, whether those frameworks have business going through them, and details of how competitive a framework is.

That would be enough to greatly improve suppliers’ experience of trying to win public sector business, which is hard enough without having to fish empty lakes.

Get in touch with us, to discuss our government procurement data, our API, or our research capabilities.

Because you read this article, you may also enjoy Analysis As A Service.

June 30, 2022

Open Data & Measuring Progress

We believe all public procurement should be sustainable and open. Recently, with our partners Open Contracting and Public, we launched a new...
June 28, 2022

Blacklisting Needs Kid Gloves

In the UK’s House of Lords debate on procurement reform, there was some forthright questioning within the government on whether Bain and...
June 22, 2022

Bain’s Woes in RSA Raises Questions in Parliament

Last week in a Lords Chamber debate, Lord Peter Hain asked why Bain & Company were still able to bid for multi-million-pound...
June 22, 2022

Procurement and impact

Governments spend over 13tn USD a year with their suppliers, or around 15% of global GDP. We’ve started analysing the carbon intensity...
June 16, 2022

Australian Pandemic PPE Contracts Cause Concern.

Much of the last two years have seen governments all over the world in a purchasing panic due to the pandemic. Understandably...
June 16, 2022

Goodbye KPIs, Hello Data Quality

There’s a truth to Tom Peter’s famous quote “what gets measured, gets done”. Peters was a writer and thinker on management practice...
June 9, 2022

National Capital Authority Under Procurement Scrutiny

The National Capital Authority (NCA) was established in 1989 under the Australian Capital Territory (Planning and Land Management) Act 1988 (PALM Act) following the...
June 7, 2022

Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity Begins

A group of Indo-Pacific nations has banded together to begin the process of developing an Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity. This framework...
May 31, 2022

Stormy Times For Meteorological Procurement

The UK government faces trial in the High Court over its award of an £854 million contract for a new Meteorological Office...
May 25, 2022

UK Left Waiting On Transparency

The UK’s latest procurement bill promises much, but many of the technical details remain to be defined. The drafting of the procurement...
May 11, 2022

Collaborative Procurement For The Construction Industry

The Centre for Built Britain has released a white paper on Procurement Strategies for incentivising collaborative delivery, which explores how a collaborative...
May 12, 2022

MoD £2 Billion in Nuclear Contracts.

Britain's Ministry of Defence announced this week that over £2 billion worth of defence contracts have been awarded to start the third...
May 10, 2022

New Support For Canadian SME Traders.

The Government of Canada recently released its 2022 Federal Budget. Within it was an announcement of an intention to establish a Trade...
April 29, 2022

Progressive Procurement Yields Results

Last year, we shared the results of the landmark Aboriginal Procurement policy (APP), first introduced by Western Australia’s Premier, Mark MacGowan in...
June 16, 2022

Cutting Carbon Is A Procurement Issue

Just a few months ago, we shared an article on findings by the Boston Consulting Group and the World Economic Forum that showed procurement...

Newsletter

Compelling research, insights and data directly into your inbox.

Recent media stories

The Times
May 30, 2022
CIPFA
August 3, 2021

Search

Scroll to Top